100 out of 114 people found the following review helpful:

Brilliantly different...

PaulaWestwood from , 27th October, 2007

This could have been so 'samey', but was so sparklingly different instead, I really expected a normal 'good' Costner film, but this had real interest intreague and differences. Costner plays Mr Brooks, a wealthy highly respected businessman, with a dark side. William Hurt as Marshall, is brilliantly cast and written as Mr Brooks dark side incarnate, the black side others cant see but is a completely real companion to Mr Brooks, the devil inside him urging him to embrace the side of him that enjoys murder, despite his resistance. But that is not all there is to this one, there is a good deal more, and all of it fascinatingly entertaining and watchable. One very small gripe (very small) the ending is a bit frayed and not quite satisfying enough... that said, I would very highly recommend this film, its certainly well above a regular movie, really good stuff.

Read all highest rated reviews

40 out of 43 people found the following review helpful:

One of the best films of 2007

Georgevader from from Chepstow, 21st August, 2007

Kevin Costner (remember him?) stars as Earl Brooks, a highly respected local businessman man, loving Husband and Father, who hides a dark secret, a psychofrenic urge to kill.The urge proves too much and when he kills two lovers in their apartment he is seen and caught on film at the scene by a sleezy photographer.The photographer (Dane Cook) though doesn't turn him into the Police or blackmail him though, he wants to learn to kill like Brooks and experience the 'thrill' first hand. Costner is superb in this film and proves something that we tend to forget, what a very, very good actor he is.Equally good is the reliable William Hurt as Marshal, Mr Brook's alter-ego, this was a great idea for the film as they discussed how they would solve issues and problems together in Mr Brook's life.Supporting cast too is a fine one, Demi Moore (remember her?) is good as the Cop pursuing the killer, CSI Vegas' Marg Heldenberger stars as Mr Brooks oblivious Wife, though I felt her character took a back seat during the second half of the movie.The lovely Reiko Aylesworth of 24 also puts in an appearance as the lawyer out to screw Demi Moore in a divorce proceedings against her money grabbing ex-husband. The script is clever and intelligent with a good dose of black humour and some neat twists, including one all mighty one at the end!!! Highly recommended.

Read all highest rated reviews

26 out of 29 people found the following review helpful:

A serial killer film with a difference

JJTimothy from , 22nd October, 2007

Earl Brooks is a successful businessman, loving patriarch and killer encouraged by an imaginary friend called Marshall. A mistake one murderous night exposes him to a shady photographer but the blackmailer doesn't want money. There was always some bafflement about Kevin Costner's popularity even during his heyday, which I admit sharing, but he was interesting when he shook off his innate wholesomeness in such films as No Way Out or Tin Cup. There was fire in his eyes as a killer on the run in A Perfect World and it flickered again recently in Open Range. Here that fire blazes and Costner commands, and holds, the attention without being flashy in a turn that merits recognition from Oscar. Dane Cook is good as the twitchy photographer and would-be killer, playing with fire by compelling Brooks to act as mentor, and Demi Moore is OK as the detective with too much back-story but this is Costner's show and, with William Hurt embodying Marshall the devil at his shoulder, he runs with it. Costner's rapport with Hurt, when Brooks relaxes into his true nature, is darkly funny and the highlight of the film but Brooks is a rounded and consistent character. Intelligent, insightful, adoring his family (Costner's wholesome image well used) and worrying about his 'addiction' even going to AA meetings in an attempt to keep it under control. He's not so concerned that he'll turn himself in mind you but perhaps his error was a subconscious attempt to be caught. At the suggestion that his daughter may have inherited his aberrant appetites Brooks is reduced to tears of despair in a believable and even sympathetic scene but his quick recovery is telling and the film does not offer this, or anything else, as excuse or redemption. Mr. Brooks is the sort of film that cannot afford to be tentative- it's politically incorrect (which I can live with) and, without its considered approach, would be hard to justify morally. Bruce A. Evans' direction is sure-footed observing horrors without revelling in or glorifying them though he does let a shoot-out go to his head rather. The cat and mouse game implied by the trailer is absent but Evans and co-writer Reynold Gideon have created a bolder, more involving story. My mother worked with a few homicidal schizophrenics in her day, as a mental health professional I hasten to point out, and when she saw the film pronounced it entirely plausible which is going to keep me awake nights. (She's discreet about details but Brooks reminded her of 'Paul' who was widely liked by institution staff- as were all such patients apparently apart from one fellow who had terrible manners. Well... good manners are important!) An audacious, off-beat character study legitimized by its authenticity and built around a committed (hah!) central performance. With black humour and a warped point of view Mr. Brooks is recommended to viewers with robust sensibilities. Now... has anyone checked if Reynold Gideon actually exists?

Read all highest rated reviews

21 out of 21 people found the following review helpful:

Exceptional

A Customer from Devon, 11th February, 2008

Edge-of-the -seat- tension; twisty clever plot; strong characterization and some amazing performances from Kevin Costner as the dedicated family man; William Hurt as his psychological dark 'demon' (with scary syncronized laughter) ; Demi Moore as the stroppy cop with her own 'demons' and Dane Cook as the hapless and seedy voyeur. Add to this menace from yet another quarter and well......Totally brilliant !!

Read all highest rated reviews

surprisingly brookey

faith from , 22nd March, 2010

this definitely was, because i was not expecting much, i just thought it was another whodunit but boy.... was it so 'not so'. there were parts of it that were really funny, i truly enjoyed it, mr brooks and the detective parts were very well done. good job. not bad for a late afternoon watch.

Read all recent reviews

Very Good

Chantal from , 21st March, 2010

A very good performance here from a disturbed cold and calculated serial killer who is also a respectable ad lovable person. But when 2 young person crash into his life, his secret risks to be exposed and his family to suffer. A cop is closing in, how will he get out of this mess and should he?

Read all recent reviews

Mr Brooks Part 1

A Customer from Essex, 13th March, 2010

If ever a film set itself up for a sequel this is it, powerful performance from Costner and an interesting film that keeps us guessing right through to the end.....and beyond

Read all recent reviews

better than expected

muggs from , 12th March, 2010

Kevin costner is not my idea actor and iv always thought you have to be a fan of his to enjoy one of his films , but Mr Brooks is different and you see a different side to Mr Costner , his proformance is deep and commited . He plays a man who has just won man of the year , he has a beutiful wife , a wonderful home but most of all he is a serial killer .Its this side of Mr Brooks that Costner plays so well . Along side Mr Brooks is his alter ego / schizophrenicside , manifested and played byWilliam Hurt , this proformance by both Costner and Hurt is excellent and they show how the two personalitys can play out in the mind of a killer . Demi moore plays the cop trying to catcj him while going through a messy devorce and huanted by an old case , giveing us are strong female role model that she plays so well .There are four story lines running in this film that all tie in , the biggest being Mr Brooks is being blackmailed by someone , he has to take this person on one of his kills or he will be reported to the police , is this the down fall of Mr Brooks or his salvation . This film is rivetting.

Read all recent reviews