Skip over navigation

Sofa Cinema

Gifts - NEW  |   Help   |   Sign in

The Fallen Idol Certificate PG

The Fallen Idol

Sign up

Rated 3.5 stars
Average rating
(69%)
 
Starring: Ralph Richardson | Michele Morgan | Dora Bryan
Director: Carol Reed
Studio: OPTIMUM HOME ENTERTAINMENT
Run time: 91 mins
Genres: Drama
Languages: English
Released: November 07, 2005

Based on a short story by Graham Greene, the plot revolves around a young boy who wrongly believes the man he idolises is guilty of murder. He sets out to influence the police investigation...

Rating of 4 stars out of 5
Radio Times

While working as a film critic in the 1930s, Graham Greene had first noticed Carol Reed's developing directorial talent. Adapted from Greene's short story The Basement Room, this was the first of their three collaborations as writer and director, and what a minor masterpiece it is. Bobby Henrey gives an exceptional performance as the ambassador's son whose attempts to help the butler he idolises only land the latter in hot water with the police after the suspicious death of the butler's wife. Credit should also go to Ralph Richardson and Michèle Morgan for allowing the boy to steal every scene in the interest of suspense.

Highest rated reviews

9 out of 11 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 1.0 stars
Why you never act with children or animals!

A Customer from Gloucester, 2nd February, 2007

Incredibly irritating child actor completely ruins an otherwise so-so thriller, fairly woodenly played. Positives are a beautiful embassy setting & some Third Man style lighting in a few city at night scenes .. but nothing to redeem a completely nauseating total experience. 'BAINES', 'BAINES'! Just clip the brat around the ear!

Read all highest rated reviews

6 out of 6 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 4.0 stars
old gold

johnnieh from , 19th March, 2008

no swearing,blood,no special effects. acting and directing goes without saying. brilliant moments excellent child actor,.If you like old films watch this.

Read all highest rated reviews

3 out of 4 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 5.0 stars
An absolute classic

Andre Barreau from Paddington, England, 16th January, 2006

Adapted from Graham Greene's short story 'The Basement Room', this late forties thriller was in many ways the precursor for The Third Man. A young ambassador's son is left alone for the weekend with the embassy's butler (Ralph Richardson) and his nagging, cruel wife. The boy is subsequently burdened with adult secrets and his naive loyalty tested to the full. More downstairs than up, this well plotted thriller bubbles up to a truly tense climax. Marvellous location shots location in and around the Eaton Square region of London add to the atmosphere of one of director Carol Reed's finest films. Warning! - the young boy's incessant calling out for the butler 'Baines' may annoy some!

Read all highest rated reviews

4 out of 7 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 5.0 stars
Excellent all round

A Customer from Oxford UK, 4th March, 2007

although a black and white film, this was superb acting, of course, as well as very good story. Thoroughly enjoyable.

Read all highest rated reviews

Most recent reviews

1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 3.0 stars
The Fallen Idol

A Customer from Falkirk, 3rd April, 2009

The attraction of this film lies in visiting the cinema of over 60 years ago. It is interesting to see bit players who later took starring roles. The boy, Bobby Henery, did not make any other films, as far as I know. He is an outstanding child actor, not irritating and precocious as so many are. The story strains belief but is cleverly managed. The characters are not too subtly drawn. Like other films of this era, there are no subtitles. As a result I found it difficult to follow all the dialogue because of a combination of poor sound and clipped accents.

Read all recent reviews

1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 3.0 stars
Through a child's eyes

A Customer from Barry, Wales, 22nd November, 2008

A boy starved of parental attention is a bit fixated on the household's butler who becomes something of a hero to him. The butler's wife, the housekeeper, is a stern governess type who keeps the boy cooped up and rules out fun at every turn. He doesn't like her. Things get complicated when it turns out that the butler is embroiled in a torrid affair. The boy discovers the couple at one of their clandestine meetings. In the ensuing drama, his loyalty works against rather for the suspected butler. Apart from one or two dropped in outdoor scenes this movie is set entirely in a large ambassadorial residence and there is a theatre play-like quality about the whole business, including its neat ending.

Read all recent reviews

2 out of 2 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 5.0 stars
The Fallen Idol

A Customer from London, 28th October, 2008

This is a classic study in hero worship by a rich but emotionally deprived child, 'a poor little rich boy', seeking, in the absence of his real parents a substitute for parental love among the servants, and from his pet snake so cruelly disposed of by the depressed husekeeper. The second theme is of marital disharmony with tragic results leading probably to the execution of the butler. You feel the child, so wonderfully and convinciingly acted, has been damaged for life by the apparent betrayal of his 'idol' Ralph Richadrson - one of his best performances, full of delicacy . A tribute to the writer, producer and camera man as well as the actors. The kindly police are also convincingly acted.

Read all recent reviews