Skip over navigation

Sofa Cinema

Gifts - NEW  |   Help   |   Sign in

Carnages (2002) Certificate 15

Carnages

Sign up

Rated 2.0 stars
Average rating
(44%)
 
Starring: Lucia Sanchez | Angela Molina | Chiara Mastroianni | Clovis Cornillac | Jacques Gamblin
Director: Delphine Gleize
Studio: PALISADES TARTAN
Run time: 128 mins
Genres: Drama | World Cinema
Languages: French
Subtitles: English
Released: March 21, 2005

After a young bullfighter is injured, the bull responsible is killed. The animal is dismembered, it's body parts parcelled up and dispatched across Europe. The story then follows the various parts of the bull as it's bones go to a supermarket where an actress sells one to a couple who give it to their daughter. The eyes go to a scientist and his wife. The horns find their way to a taxidermist and it's steaks to a restaurant.

Rating of 2 stars out of 5
Radio Times

Acclaimed shorts director Delphine Gleize allows ambition to get the better of her in a feature debut that seeks to link seamlessly several tenuously connected stories only to end up shortchanging them all. The unifying factor is a bull that gores matador Julien Lescarret before being slaughtered and having its carcass dispatched into the orbit of, among others, struggling Italian actress Chiara Mastroianni, guilt-ridden Spaniard Angela Molina, adulterous French scientist Jacques Gamblin and hyper-imaginative child Raphaëlle Molinier. Gleize invests the diverse scenarios with arch significance, but the majority are inconsequential, while others come perilously close to being ridiculous.

Highest rated reviews

1 out of 1 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 3 stars
Interesting Concept

Matti White from London, UK, 21st July, 2006

In this film, director Delphine Gleize attempts to connect several seperate short stories, primarily by way of a dead bull! Although this is an interesting idea, the links between the stories are often rather stretched, and the way she jumps between them is, at times, slightly confusing to the viewer. The stories themselves are quite interesting at times, and at others, lacklustre - the end portion of the film is particularly disappointing, as many of the plot threads explored in the film seem to either fizzle out or be completely ignored, and many of the 'twists' are quite obvious to the viewer. Having said all this, the acting is of a high standard - Five year old Raphaëlle Molinier is particularly impressive in her brilliant portrayal of the eccentric 'Winnie'! I think this film would have worked much better if it had been presented as a series of seperate short films - then the stories would have been paramount, instead of focussing on making tenuous connections between them.

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 4 stars
This film was a delight..

Piccolina from , 11th February, 2010

Carnages was actually an unexpected delight of a film. Quite a magical little tale of how a bull that was killed after a brutal bullfight affects so many lives and ties them all together. As the body parts of the bull are split across 3 countries, people whose lives were never obviously connected now become inextricably linked, bringing out all manner of brilliant characterization and some eccentric personalities. I just love the little girl, Winnie, and her dog, Fred; and Chiara Mastroianni, Catherine Devenue’s daughter, is wonderfully quirky in this. A charming little story, visually beautiful, its scenes are almost rhythmic. I shall look out for more of Delphine Gleize’s work.

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 2 stars
A lot of bull

IJH from Newcastle, England, 30th August, 2005

A frustrating experience from this film with ambitions towards Amores Perros. The contrived threads begin with promise, but after an hour or so without development, my origanal intrigue gave way to apathy. It's never really dull, but it does leave you feeling rather unsatisfied by the end.

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 4 stars
Carnages

FranLord from Hampshire, 12th June, 2005

An excellent film. Like a Claude Letouch film it weaves together a different set of people into one whole film. Stongly recommended.

Read all highest rated reviews