7 out of 7 people found the following review helpful:

Ignore the last review!

MovieLoon from , 1st September, 2009

Sterling performance as always from the fantsastic Mr Hardy as an intense, raw Heathcliffe. Previous adaptations of Wuthering Heights seem brittle compared to this tour de force. A must for all period drama lovers.

Read all highest rated reviews

5 out of 5 people found the following review helpful:

Terrible Heathcliff

A Customer from London, 9th September, 2009

I can't believe anyone thought Hardy was good in this. He was totally one-dimensional and painful to watch (and how about his all-over-the-place accent/voice? Every time he opened his mouth, I had flashbacks of Alan Partrige singing the Kate Bush song). There was no sense of his love for Cathy at all, or his inner torment and his desire to belong. All you got was the bullying, unpleasant and cruel side of his personality- it made Cathy's obsession with him completely unplausible and as a result she also came across as brittle and annoying. The rest of the cast (Sarah Lancashire and Andrew Lincoln) delivered some solid performances (if miscast- I'm pretty sure Edgar is not meant to be sexier than Heathcliff!) but that was not enough by any means. HUGE disappointment.

Read all highest rated reviews

4 out of 4 people found the following review helpful:

Brilliant

A Customer from Telford, 1st September, 2009

I am still amazed at how good Tom Hardy was as Heathcliff. The best I've ever seen. Really haunting and memorable. The whole adaptation - though sorrowfully not enough like the book - was unmissable and I would thoroughly recommend it to anyone.

Read all highest rated reviews

6 out of 11 people found the following review helpful:

Crikey, this was diabolical

MoggyMania from , 31st August, 2009

Maybe it is unfair to review something that I was unable to watch entirely, but after 10 minutes or so it just had to be switched off. Although I am a huge fan of the book and have read it many times, and thoroughly enjoy the Ralph Fiennes/Juliet Binoche version of the film, this was so appalling that I have had to submit my first-ever review - the acting was terrible, the accents dreadful (and I'm from Yorkshire so I should know!) and it bore little resemblance to the book. Worst adaptation since the new Brideshead Revisited! What were they thinking of? Heathcliff had all the charisma of a tramp. Although I am not averse to new adaptations, and infact prefer the new Pride and Prejudice to the original (Colin Firth is brilliant, it has to be said), this one should be given a miss by any Bronte Fans out there. The latest Jane Eyre adaptation is fantastic and I was hoping this was going to be of a similar quality, but I was very disappointed as you have probably guessed!

Read all highest rated reviews

*** May contain spoilers ***

If adaptation is neccessary, at least do it properly

A Customer from Cheshire, 17th November, 2009

Very disappointed particularly by the ending. He didn't shoot himself! He went on hunger strike and willed himself to die over a number of years. At the time of writing, suicides couldn't be buried near loved ones and the whole point was that he wanted to wander the moors with Cathy in the afterlife. His death was symbolic of his heartbreak and pain, so this ending was totally inaccurate and false in relation to the book.Fiennes/Binoche version was much better

Read all recent reviews

3 out of 3 people found the following review helpful:

Healthcliff

A Customer from Watford, 2nd September, 2009

My wife this TV drama adaption. Tom Hardy is a brilliant actor. Heathciff was portrayed with passion. The link which ties Cathy and Heathcliff is astounding. A must see..

Read all recent reviews