Skip over navigation

Sofa Cinema

Gifts - NEW  |   Help   |   Sign in

Proposition, The - BLU-RAY Version (2006) Certificate 18

Proposition, The - BLU-RAY Version

Sign up

Rated 3.0 stars
Average rating
(64%)
 
Starring: Guy Pearce | Ray Winstone | Danny Huston | John Hurt | David Wenham | Emily Watson | Tom Budge
Director: John Hillcoat
Studio: PALISADES TARTAN
Run time: 100 mins
Genres: Action/Adventure
Languages: English
Released: June 23, 2008

Australian director John Hillcoat first teamed up with singer Nick Cave on 1988's disturbing GHOSTS...OF THE CIVIL DEAD, for which Cave co-authored the screenplay and took a memorably brief acting role. The two reconvene for 2006's THE PROPOSITION, with Cave penning the screenplay and providing a soundtrack written with Dirty Three member Warren Ellis. Cave's 19th-century tale begins with the proposition of the title, as Captain Stanley (Ray Winstone) captures fugitive brothers Charley (Guy Pearce) and Mikey Burns (Richard Wilson) at a scene of bloody rape and murder. Informing Charley that he must kill his older brother, Arthur (Danny Huston), in order to be set free, Stanley drags Mikey to a decrepit jailhouse while he waits for Charley to carry out the deed. Hillcoat's Western reeks of the dry desert heat, with flies buzzing, temperatures soaring, and emotions spiralling out of control. As Charley reluctantly sets about his task, Hillcoat and cinematographer Benoit Delhomme create a mesmerising vision of the Australian outback. The slow, meandering pace of the film is peppered with brutal jolts of unremitting violence, and there are fine performances from the entire cast, who are supported in small but significant roles from Emily Watson (BREAKING THE WAVES) and John Hurt (THE ELEPHANT MAN). Cave's screenplay is tight and focused, leaving little room for sentiment or anyone for the audience to root for by giving all his principal characters plenty of grimly undesirable personality traits. But it works perfectly, and in Winstone and Pearce, Hillcoat got his casting exactly right. Both actors give dizzying performances as two men unable to escape their personal demons, finding a tragic outlet only in ceaseless acts of aggression. A memorable feature that lingers long after the last frame of celluloid has flickered onto the screen, THE PROPOSITION establishes Hillcoat as a director of major gravitas.

Highest rated reviews

5 out of 6 people found the following review helpful:

Rated 5.0 stars
great work from NIck Cave

rosser31 from , 24th September, 2008

Beautiful and sometimes brutal film that could be called ' The Birth of Australia'. Intelligent script and sensitive characterisations.

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 5.0 stars
Impressive

A Customer from Exeter, 11th February, 2010

Impressive acting, great plot and super sound track

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 4.0 stars
Close..very close

Bob Bentley from London, england, 9th February, 2010

I found the film JUST about held the tension and menace, via the characters, and kept me interested for the full movie. It was close to being over long and too drudgy, and would have been with other actors. I thought Ray Winstone was superb and portrayed strength and vunerability very well. I always like Guy Pearce but didnt find his pretty much silent character gave him much to use. There were flashes of the angst of the decision he has to make - but not enough. The look of the film was excellent with lovely landscapes. I found the music became noticable only at the right points. The style of the music fitted the film well despite being from a different era. * SPOILER BELOW * I felt the story itself held very little surprise. I dont always need a twist but there were only two ways this would go. 1. He goes off, kills his brother, returns to save his other brother and gain revenge. 2. He goes off, returns with his brother to rescue Mikey, then kills his older brother. There was the darker possible ending where Charlie Burns after rescuing Mikey joins in with his brothers on the revenge. However, I like that Captain Stanley had read Charlie correctly i.e. that the violence stemmed from Arthur primarily and Charlie wasnt happy with the situation (he had after all run away from the gang before the proposition was made)

Read all highest rated reviews

Rated 2.0 stars
Like revving the car but not actually going anywhere

A Customer from Yorkshire, England, 25th November, 2009

I fell asleep during this movie which I haven't done in over a year, a minute and a half on a scene and all that is said, you really should eat something. I get why the scenes are there, but the movie seems to develop momentum to then hit a brick wall. Quite a frustrating film, could have been edited better, more of the reel should have ended up on the floor.

Read all highest rated reviews